Episode 50 How to Strengthen Your Leadership Identity
In this milestone 50th episode, Sarah shares a vital episode for ambitious female leaders - how to strengthen your leadership identity. Sarah explores the invisible yet powerful biases that still affect women in leadership and reveals three practical ways to build visibility, voice, and value so you can lead with confidence, authenticity, and impact.
Plus, she announces a special competition to win a 1:1 coaching session in celebration of reaching 50 episodes!
Show Notes
[00:00:00] Welcome & Introduction
[00:02:15] Competition Announcement 🎉
To celebrate, Sarah invites listeners to leave a 5-star review and message her for a chance to win a free 1:1 coaching session.
[00:03:00] Why Leadership Identity Matters
Why this topic is so important for women in leadership roles.
[00:04:00] The Invisible Web of Biases
Four common biases that impact women leaders:
- Affinity bias – promoting people like ourselves
- Performance vs. potential bias – men promoted on potential, women on proof
- Double bind – being both competent and likable
- Prove-it-again bias – women must continually re-prove their competence
[00:08:30] The Impact of These Biases
How these biases drain energy, cause over-preparation, self-doubt, and can make leadership feel like an uphill battle.
[00:09:00] 3 Layers of Leadership Credibility: Visibility, Voice, and Value
A framework for strengthening your leadership identity:
- Visibility – Be strategic about who sees your work and ensure decision-makers know your impact.
Action: Ask yourself, “Do key decision-makers know about my recent wins?”
- Voice – Use your voice intentionally to share ideas, influence, and inspire others.
Action: Reflect on whether you’re contributing meaningfully in meetings and what you want to be known for.
- Value – Demonstrate your strategic thinking and broader business impact.
Action: Take “radical responsibility” for contributing to wider organizational issues.
[00:13:00] 3 Practical Actions to Strengthen Your Leadership Identity
- Audit your personal leadership brand – Ask three colleagues what strength they associate with you.
- Seek strategic sponsors – Identify advocates who can champion you when you’re not in the room.
- Own your leadership narrative – Believe in your story and communicate it with confidence.
“Remember, you’re capable of more than you know. Shine brightly, lead boldly, and unlock the extraordinary potential within you. Be unstoppable.”
Useful Links
Free: Break Free From Imposter Syndrome Webinar
Sign up for Weekly Career Inspiration
Learn about Leadership & Advancement Coaching Programmes
Join The Love What You Do Facebook Group
Connect with Sarah on LinkedIn
Rate & Review the Podcast
If you found this episode of Unstuck & Unstoppable helpful, please do rate and review it on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
If you're kind enough to leave a review, please do let Sarah know so she can say thank you. You can always reach her at: sarah@careertreecoaching.co.uk
Mentioned in this episode:
Free Webinar
https://www.careertreecoaching.co.uk/imposter-syndrome-webinar
Transcript
Welcome to Unstuck and Unstoppable,
the podcast for ambitious female
2
:leaders who want to create more impact,
income, and influence in their careers.
3
:feel connected to their passion
and purpose, but without
4
:selling out or burning out.
5
:I'm Sarah Archer, a leadership coach
and career strategist, helping women
6
:like you thrive in leadership roles
while staying true to your values.
7
:I'm the founder of CareerTree
Coaching and have over 15 years of
8
:coaching experience and significant HR
leadership experience to share with you.
9
:I know as a female leader it can
be hard to find time to focus
10
:on your career aspirations.
11
:The day job can be all consuming.
12
:Plus, no matter how senior you are,
there are always going to be times
13
:when you feel stuck, when you have
self doubt, or feel like an imposter.
14
:And that's where unstuck
and unstoppable comes in.
15
:Each week I'll be sharing practical
strategies, insightful interviews and
16
:inspiring stories to help you boost
your confidence, lead with purpose
17
:and achieve sustainable success.
18
:If you're ready to stop playing
small and unlock the incredible
19
:potential you have within you and feel
unstoppable, you're in the right place.
20
:Let's get started.
21
:Welcome to episode 50.
22
:I can't believe that we've actually
recorded 50 episodes and I've just
23
:come back from my business retreat
in Spain and this time last year.
24
:Or at the retreat last year,
the podcast idea was born.
25
:So it's quite nice that I've hit
50 episodes just as I come back
26
:from a retreat a year later.
27
:So yeah, so it's crazy.
28
:But I'm so pleased that you
are enjoying the podcast.
29
:Thank you for your messages, letting
me know that you're really enjoying it.
30
:I love doing the recordings.
31
:It's just fantastic.
32
:To be able to share some of
these theories, tools, ideas,
33
:inspiration with you, and today's
topic is no different really.
34
:Before we get into today's topic,
I've got a little competition for
35
:you to celebrate the 50th episode.
36
:So if you leave me a review, if you've
enjoyed any of the episodes, leave me a
37
:review or a five star rating and message
me to tell me that you've done that.
38
:I will pop you into a drawer to win.
39
:, A one-to-one coaching session with me.
40
:So we'll keep it open
until the 18th of November.
41
:And , I will then announce on the
podcast episode that week who has won
42
:the draw and obviously message them
43
:. So good luck with that.
44
:Today's topic is a
really interesting topic.
45
:And vital for female leaders as well.
46
:The reason I chose it, so how to
strengthen your leadership identity
47
:was because a lot of clients that I'm
working with at the moment, female
48
:clients, female leaders, are struggling
with some of this identity work
49
:even in progressive organizations.
50
:I think it's important that we talk about.
51
:What's going on that can get in the
way of our leadership success that is
52
:outside of our control because we have
seen an awareness for these societal and
53
:organizational biases that exist despite
all the great DEI work that has been done.
54
:Those biases are still around, even
in the most progressive organizations
55
:they are around to a degree.
56
:So understanding them and knowing
how to navigate them through having
57
:a strong leadership identity.
58
:Is really important.
59
:What I'm gonna do today is run through
, some of those biases to remind you
60
:of what they are, and then talk about
three ways that you can strengthen your
61
:leadership identity and three actions you
can take away to put into practice today.
62
:These biases exist and they create
this , web, invisible web that we
63
:then have to navigate US leaders
because biases aren't loud.
64
:They're not obvious, they're
subtle, they're quiet, and
65
:sometimes we forget about them.
66
:And we think it's more to do with USS
than it is to do with what's going on
67
:unseen in the organization, the first one
that we are aware of is affinity bias,
68
:and that's where leaders tend to promote.
69
:People that remind them of themselves.
70
:If it's a male dominated promotion
panel or interview panel, they are
71
:more likely to promote a man than
a woman into that leadership role.
72
:There's also the performance versus
potential bias as well, where studies
73
:have shown that men are promoted more
based on their potential for the role
74
:where women are promoted based on their
proven experience, meaning that women are
75
:often overqualified for the role that they
want because they have to prove they've
76
:already done it, rather than mending,
promoted based on their potential.
77
:And, this isn't, about
being negative about men.
78
:'cause you're gonna be working with
some great men in your workplace.
79
:It's about the societal barriers
and biases that are there
80
:that women also have as well.
81
:Some of the studies will show that,
we are demonstrating those biases
82
:alongside our male counterparts.
83
:A Harvard study found that if a man and
a woman both achieve the same result,
84
:the man is more likely to be seen as
strategic, whereas the woman is more
85
:likely to be seen as hardworking.
86
:So this is why thinking about
these biases demonstrates why it's
87
:important that we own our leadership
identity and our narrative.
88
:Because we're gonna be more
in control of the perceptions
89
:about us, which otherwise can.
90
:Derail our leadership success.
91
:We've also got the double bind, which
you probably are aware of, which
92
:is likability versus competence.
93
:A woman has to demonstrate, not only is
she competent to do the job, but she's
94
:also warm, likable, and collaborative.
95
:And we know that, if a woman.
96
:Perhaps puts that to one side and
just focuses on doing the job.
97
:They can be seen as cold they can be seen
as pushy, they can be seen as aggressive.
98
:So you're always feeling that you've got
to walk that very fine line between not
99
:being too warm and too likable so that
you're not taken seriously in terms of
100
:the message you're trying to get across.
101
:But then again, not not demonstrating
that likability because.
102
:Not only do we have to be competent,
we have to be seen as being
103
:somebody that people could get along
with, that can be seen as being
104
:collaborative, whereas a male colleague
doesn't have to demonstrate that.
105
:There was an interesting bit of
research done by Cheryl Sandberg.
106
:Which was published in the Harvard
Business Review where participants were
107
:asked, and so male female participants
were asked to rate a successful
108
:entrepreneur's leadership style.
109
:And they were told the leader
was male, and the found him
110
:to be confident and competent.
111
:They were given the same information,
but were told that the entrepreneur
112
:was female and they found her
to be self-promoting and harsh.
113
:This is why controlling our own
narrative and building up our
114
:leadership identity is so important
because we can't control those biases.
115
:We can only control ourselves and how we
are projecting ourselves into the world.
116
:Then the final one is the prove it
again, bias, which is similar to the
117
:potential bias, whereas women have
to repeatedly prove their competence.
118
:Women are less likely to be seen
as risk takers in a study done by
119
:Korn Ferry, and therefore they were
passed over for decision making roles
120
:that required bold decision making.
121
:So it's again, having to prove that
you have that competence, that you have
122
:that capability rather than potential.
123
:Now, this constant pressure of these
biases means that often as female leaders,
124
:we feel this needs to always be over
prepared for speaking up in meetings.
125
:We always have to make sure we've ticked
all the boxes before we apply for that
126
:leadership role, or we go for promotion.
127
:We often undersell our
achievements because we don't
128
:want to be seen as bragging.
129
:The result is that you spend a lot of
energy trying to navigate all these
130
:unseen barriers to leadership success.
131
:And, it could often feel like it's that
uphill battle the whole time to have the
132
:leadership success that you want because
of this invisible web in the organization
133
:that you're trying to navigate.
134
:Let's move now to what
you can do about it.
135
:Because you can't single
handedly change that.
136
:Over time we're hoping that those
biases are going to become less and
137
:less, but they're still prevalent
in lots of organizations, even
138
:, really progressive organizations.
139
:And obviously what's going on in
America is not helping either.
140
:The three things that you can think about
to do to build your leadership identity
141
:and really own it, is to think about the
three layers of leadership credibility.
142
:So that's visibility, voice, and value.
143
:Visibility, if we take that one first.
144
:That is being strategic about
your leadership visibility.
145
:I talk a lot about personal
leadership branding with my clients,
146
:so it's being really clear about.
147
:Your leadership brand and how you
want to communicate that and who
148
:you want to communicate that to.
149
:So identifying who are the key
decision makers in your organization.
150
:'cause remember, your energy is precious.
151
:You don't want to be spreading this,
visibility far and why it's better to
152
:be targeted about who you want to be
visible to and what you want 'em to know
153
:about you so that you are on their radar.
154
:You are confident to talk about.
155
:The work that you're doing, the
challenge of the work that you're
156
:doing, the complexity of the work
that you're doing, so they get a real
157
:understanding of what you are bringing
to the business and to the organization.
158
:And you want to be invited to the
rooms where decisions are made.
159
:So having that visibility will mean
that you are going to be included
160
:in those key decision making
discussions because they can see
161
:the value add that you are bringing.
162
:One quick action you could do is to ask
yourself, do the key decision makers in
163
:my organization know about my recent wins?
164
:Am I telling people enough people,
the right people about what I'm doing
165
:and the success that I'm bringing,
the value add that I'm making.
166
:The second one is voice, and that is
your leadership voice in terms of how
167
:you express your ideas and the influence
and impact you have through your voice.
168
:So again, thinking about the
different opportunities you have to.
169
:Articulate your ideas and your influence.
170
:Are you doing seeing stakeholders?
171
:Are you doing it with
your boss and your peers?
172
:Are you doing it with your team and
creating opportunities for you to
173
:have the the chance to influence the
impact and make impact in meetings?
174
:Doing a quick audit of, in the
last meeting that I was in, did I
175
:feel like I had the opportunity to.
176
:To speak the opportunity to share
my ideas, the opportunities to ask
177
:questions, the opportunity to get
people to have a different perspective.
178
:'cause it's not always
about asserting your views.
179
:It might be asking great questions
that make people think differently.
180
:And again, it comes back to your branding.
181
:What do you want to be
known for in those meetings?
182
:Are you getting that across?
183
:And the third thing is the value that
you are bringing to the organization
184
:because you're probably really great at
what you do in terms of delivery, but
185
:you also want to be showing that you
are a strategic thinker and a strategic
186
:business partner to the organization.
187
:How are you demonstrating that big
picture thinking within the organization?
188
:And part of that could be about
taking radical responsibility
189
:in your organization.
190
:Not just thinking about your area of
expertise, your department, your team,
191
:but what are the wider issues in the
business that you could take some radical
192
:responsibility for enabling other people
to solve or be involved in yourself in
193
:terms of solving those bigger picture?
194
:Wider organizational issues, which
again, will showcase the value that
195
:you are bringing to the organization.
196
:And if one of your leadership brand
elements is about being a creative
197
:problem solver, then it might be that
you are asking great questions that
198
:help the organization solve problems.
199
:It might not be solving those problems
yourself in terms of implementation,
200
:but it might be you want to be known
for, bringing that creative thinking
201
:to organizational wide problems.
202
:Again, it's coming back to what do you
want to be known for in your organization
203
:in terms of your leadership identity?
204
:So three actions you can take to start
creating your leadership identity or
205
:strengthening your leadership identity.
206
:One would be to audit your personal
leadership brand so you know, what
207
:are you known for in the organization,
what do you want to be known for?
208
:And your brand is what people say
about you when you're not in the room.
209
:One thing you could do, which
can be a real eyeopener, is just
210
:ask three trusted colleagues.
211
:What is one strength that
they associate with you?
212
:This could be a confirmation of your
leadership brand if they're coming back
213
:with the strengths that you are wanting
to communicate to the organization.
214
:But if it's not, it could be a great
opportunity to either identify the
215
:strengths that you haven't been
playing up to, or it might be about
216
:actually realizing that things you're
communicating are playing down your
217
:strengths that you want to be known for.
218
:So that can be one great
thing to think about doing.
219
:The second thing is seeking
out strategic sponsors.
220
:You might have a mentor, which is
great, who can give you advice and
221
:support, but sponsors can be champions.
222
:They can be advocates for you.
223
:They can be door openers.
224
:If you don't have sponsors in
the organization or externally.
225
:It could be a great thing in terms
of your leadership identity to be
226
:associated with a sponsor that you
really connect with and you can
227
:develop a reciprocal arrangement with.
228
:It's not just about them doing
everything for you, it's about you
229
:supporting them and also building the
relationship that you have with them.
230
:Thinking about who in my organization
do I really want to build a strong
231
:relationship with, that they could
also become a sponsor and advocate
232
:for me within the organization.
233
:So when you are not in the room, that
sponsor could be floating your name
234
:as somebody who could deliver great
things to the organization or be part
235
:of a project or have an opportunity
that would help your leadership career.
236
:And the third one, which is
perhaps the most important, is
237
:really owning your narrative.
238
:If you don't believe your
leadership story, then how can
239
:you expect other people in the
organization to believe it too?
240
:Self validating.
241
:So owning your leadership successes,
owning your leadership strengths, being
242
:really clear about them, how they fit
into your leadership brand, and being
243
:confident, communicating those strengths
and your story within the organization.
244
:In terms of that audit, what are you
going to be wanting to communicate around
245
:your story of how you've become a leader?
246
:Okay.
247
:I hope that by strengthening your
leadership identity, owning your
248
:narrative, defining your leadership brand,
building your voice, visibility and value.
249
:You're going to be better able
then to navigate some of those
250
:biases that we are going to face as
female leaders in the organization.
251
:And I'd love to know what you're
gonna take away and actually try
252
:out in terms of strengthening
your current leadership identity.
253
:So are you going to audit your brand?
254
:Are you gonna seek a sponsor?
255
:Are you gonna do some work
around your leadership narrative?
256
:I would love to know that.
257
:You don't have to do it alone, it is
also about thinking what do you need to
258
:help you strengthen your leadership?
259
:To, and if it's something you
would like some leadership coaching
260
:around, then please do get in touch.
261
:I can offer you a free strategy call
where we can work through what are
262
:the key things you're gonna need some
help with to get you to where you
263
:want to be in your leadership career.
264
:Thank you so much for listening
to this episode of the Unstuck
265
:and Unstoppable podcast.
266
:I have lots of free resources you
can access on my website, ww.career
267
:tree coaching.co
268
:uk, and I'll also put
links in the show notes.
269
:If you found this episode
helpful, then please subscribe
270
:so you don't miss the next one.
271
:And please do share it with a
friend and leave me a review
272
:and I will personally thank you.
273
:Remember, you're capable of more
than you know, shine brightly.
274
:Lead boldly and unlock the
extraordinary potential within you.
275
:Be unstoppable.