Episode 48 How to sell yourself with confidence in your next leadership interview
In this episode, Sarah dives into how to confidently sell yourself in your next leadership interview, without feeling fake, boastful, or uncomfortable.
Drawing on her extensive experience coaching senior leaders, Sarah shares practical mindset shifts, communication strategies, and evidence-based techniques to help you move from self-doubt to self-assurance. Whether you’re interviewing for a director or CEO role, this episode will help you show your true value with confidence and impact.
Show Notes
[00:00:00] Welcome & Introduction
[00:01:00] Why This Topic Matters
Inspired by a client’s recent success in securing a director-level role, Sarah explains why interview confidence is a crucial skill for senior leaders and why “selling yourself” doesn’t have to feel uncomfortable.
[00:02:30] The Challenges of Leadership Interviews
How senior-level interviews differ from earlier career ones - more stages, more scrutiny, and higher expectations - and how preparation and mindset make all the difference.
[00:04:00] What You’ll Learn in This Episode
- How to shift your mindset from “Am I good enough?” to “How can I show the value I bring?”
- What interviewers really want to know about you
- How to convey your strengths without downplaying them
- How to communicate with impact and authenticity
[00:05:00] Reframing ‘Selling Yourself’
Instead of thinking of interviews as sales pitches, Sarah reframes them as opportunities to present evidence-based data about your value and achievements.
[00:06:00] Managing Your Inner Critic
Practical ways to silence self-doubt and build a positive mindset before interviews - from affirmations to perspective shifts. Includes real client examples of how mindset work leads to interview success.
[00:08:00] Defining Your Unique Value
How to identify your unique selling points and demonstrate how you make a measurable difference to an organisation - whether through growth, people, innovation, or efficiency.
[00:10:00] Understanding the Interview Panel
How to tailor your responses based on who’s on the panel - your future boss, HR, peers, or board members - and what each is looking for in a candidate.
[00:12:00] Communicating Your Strengths with Ease
Why humility can hold leaders back - and how to practice talking about your achievements naturally so it feels authentic, not boastful.
[00:13:00] Balancing Strategy and Delivery
A reminder that senior roles require both operational experience and strategic thinking and how to showcase both effectively.
[00:14:00] Creating Personal Impact
How to let your enthusiasm and authenticity shine through, show your human side, and build rapport with the panel. How small moments of honesty can create connection.
[00:16:00] Be Intentional About Your Impact
Tips for being deliberate about how you want to come across - whether as a visionary leader, safe pair of hands, or collaborative people person.
[00:17:00] Recap & Key Takeaways
Summary of the five key areas to focus on for your next leadership interview:
- Reframe selling as sharing evidence.
- Manage your inner critic and mindset.
- Know your unique value and what the panel needs to hear.
- Communicate your strengths with ease and authenticity.
- Create personal impact through presence and enthusiasm.
[00:18:00] Closing & Resources
Sarah encourages listeners to connect for 1:1 interview coaching
Useful Links
Free Break Free From Imposter Syndrome Webinar
Sign up for Weekly Career Inspiration
Learn about Leadership & Advancement Coaching Programmes
Join The Love What You Do Facebook Group
Connect with Sarah on LinkedIn
Rate & Review the Podcast
If you found this episode of Unstuck & Unstoppable helpful, please do rate and review it on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
If you're kind enough to leave a review, please do let Sarah know so she can say thank you. You can always reach her at: sarah@careertreecoaching.co.uk
Transcript
Welcome to Unstuck and Unstoppable,
the podcast for ambitious female
2
:leaders who want to create more impact,
income, and influence in their careers.
3
:feel connected to their passion
and purpose, but without
4
:selling out or burning out.
5
:I'm Sarah Archer, a leadership coach
and career strategist, helping women
6
:like you thrive in leadership roles
while staying true to your values.
7
:I'm the founder of CareerTree
Coaching and have over 15 years of
8
:coaching experience and significant HR
leadership experience to share with you.
9
:I know as a female leader it can
be hard to find time to focus
10
:on your career aspirations.
11
:The day job can be all consuming.
12
:Plus, no matter how senior you are,
there are always going to be times
13
:when you feel stuck, when you have
self doubt, or feel like an imposter.
14
:And that's where unstuck
and unstoppable comes in.
15
:Each week I'll be sharing practical
strategies, insightful interviews and
16
:inspiring stories to help you boost
your confidence, lead with purpose
17
:and achieve sustainable success.
18
:Welcome to episode 48.
19
:I'm really pleased you're
here with me today.
20
:I decided this would be a great topic
for us to talk about because I was
21
:coaching somebody end of last week who's
going for a director level role, and
22
:the interview was on Monday this week,
and so we were doing some interview prep
23
:and it reminded me that this is such
a great topic for the podcast because.
24
:Interviews at senior levels are hard.
25
:There's often a number of stages, and
the level of performance is so much
26
:more than maybe when you were going
for, a role earlier in your career.
27
:And so I wanted to share some.
28
:, Useful techniques and tips with you
today, and I was delighted when my
29
:client messaged me on Monday after the
interview to say it had gone really well.
30
:She was really pleased
with how she'd performed.
31
:And then she also messaged me later in the
day to say she'd had a call from the chief
32
:exec and they had offered her the job.
33
:So I was super pleased that the
prep we'd done had just given her
34
:that extra boost of confidence to
perform really well in the interview.
35
:And so today's topic, as you've
probably guessed, is all about how
36
:to sell yourself confidently at
your next leadership interview.
37
:I do a lot of leadership, interview,
coaching because no matter how senior
38
:you are, the interview process always
feels quite challenging to be able
39
:to walk in there confidently and
talk about yourself for an hour.
40
:So perfect strangers often
can feel really unnatural.
41
:It can feel uncomfortable and
it can put people off going
42
:for that next level role.
43
:Which is why I love interview coaching
because there's lots of small things you
44
:can do that can make a big impact on your.
45
:Interview impacts, and that's
what we're gonna talk about today.
46
:Also, let's face it, often there are
a number of interviews you've got
47
:to get through to get the job offer.
48
:I'm working with a client at the
moment who's going for a CEO role, and
49
:she already knows there's at least.
50
:Three stages in the interview
process with different stakeholders
51
:and also with the client group.
52
:And so we're working now to prepare
her for those interviews that are gonna
53
:happen within the next, month, six weeks.
54
:What we're gonna cover today is how to
shift your mindset from am I good enough
55
:to, how can I show the value that I bring?
56
:We are going to look at
what the interviewers really
57
:want to know about you.
58
:We're gonna talk about how to
convey your strengths and your
59
:skills without downplaying them.
60
:And we're going to think about how you
can communicate with impact as well.
61
:Now, obviously we're gonna, we've
only got 15 minutes, so it is gonna
62
:be top level, but it's gonna give
you the opportunity to think about.
63
:Your interview technique, your interview
performance and what are the areas perhaps
64
:you need to tweak or to concentrate on
to uplift your interview performance.
65
:If this is something that you
really struggle with, then
66
:you do get in contact with me.
67
:We can have a chat about how interview
coaching, which would be tailored to
68
:you, can help you navigate your next
leadership interview differently.
69
:Okay, so the first thing I want
you to think about is how we
70
:can reframe selling yourself.
71
:To something different because
just that whole concept of having
72
:to sell, having to self-promote,
can leave you feeling a bit icky.
73
:It can leave you feeling a
bit, oh, I don't wanna do that.
74
:So what I try and do with
clients is help them to see that
75
:actually we want to reframe this.
76
:Into, it's about detailing exactly
why you would be an asset to
77
:the company or the organization.
78
:So we are thinking about it in terms
of data, information and facts.
79
:Evidence because interviews
are evidence-based.
80
:We're thinking about sharing
information rather than necessarily
81
:having to sell yourself.
82
:And it's to give them information
that will help them make a good
83
:decision, an evidence-based decision.
84
:So that can take the pressure off
a little bit because sometimes
85
:that pressure to sell yourself can
just make you feel I can't do this.
86
:I had a client who I worked with at
the end of last year who was going
87
:for a head of programs role who
came to me because she just felt she
88
:crumbled at interviews and that whole
self-promotion piece felt really alien
89
:to her and it really put her off.
90
:And so we did a lot of reframing around.
91
:It being evidence-based and she
was presenting data and facts about
92
:herself and how she added value.
93
:That enabled her then to navigate the
first interview, which she felt she
94
:didn't do very well in, but she did 'cause
she got through to second interview and
95
:then she got the job offer and it really
helped her reframe the interview process
96
:so it could feel more accessible to her.
97
:The second thing we want to do is to
think about managing your inner critic.
98
:So that you can create a positive
mindset around the interview process.
99
:'cause often when we
think about interviews, we
100
:experience a sense of dread.
101
:We experience a sense of, I would really
rather be ill on the day, or some reason
102
:that I can't get to the office or my
internet goes down, rather than take the
103
:interview, which obviously going into the
interview with that kind of mindset can
104
:. Inhibit you and not allow you
to be presenting your best self.
105
:We want to be going
into the interview now.
106
:We're gonna feel nervous, but
feeling excitement for it,
107
:feeling positive towards it in
terms of It's a conversation.
108
:It's a dialogue.
109
:And the key to that is managing
your inner critic and also being
110
:able to tap into, thinking about
the interview in a positive way.
111
:So sometimes using things like
affirmations to just be able to uplift.
112
:The way you are going to
approach the interview.
113
:I had another client who I've worked
with three times around interview
114
:coaching for different roles, all
that she's been successful in.
115
:And the first interview that I
worked with her was for a finance
116
:director role that she was going for.
117
:It's her first financial
director role, and she was
118
:somebody who had worked her way.
119
:Through different roles in finance.
120
:So she'd started as a finance assistant
and over time she had progressed and
121
:she'd become qualified and she'd got
to achieve senior roles in finance.
122
:But she had a little voice in her head
that was saying, am I good enough?
123
:Can I do an leadership role?
124
:What can I bring that would
get me, a seat at the table?
125
:And so we had to do work around her
mindset and helping her feel good
126
:enough and to feel positive around
the whole interview experience.
127
:And I could see from working with her,
she had amazing commercial acumen.
128
:She could really see how she
could add value to the business
129
:beyond just the finances.
130
:She was thinking about the whole
commercial piece and things the
131
:business could do to . Fine tune
and hold its commercial approach.
132
:And this came across in her interviews
and she's been successful in all
133
:the finance director role interviews
that I've supported her with because
134
:she can bring this real added value.
135
:So that mindset piece is really key.
136
:The third area that we'd want to
think about is getting clear about
137
:what the panel need to know about
me in order to offer me the job.
138
:That's getting really clear about
what your unique selling points are
139
:that you are bringing, that's gonna
help you stand out as a candidate.
140
:It's gonna be different to what somebody
else might bring, but also linking it to
141
:what makes a difference for a business.
142
:Often if you're thinking about the
business or the organization, you're
143
:going to be thinking about, am I making
a difference in any of these categories?
144
:So it could be around growth.
145
:It could be around revenue,
increasing revenue or income.
146
:It could be around people, it could be
around innovation, it could be around
147
:risk, and it could be around . Efficiency.
148
:So thinking about how do I add value?
149
:What difference do I make to the business?
150
:Bottom line around those areas.
151
:And being able to showcase that in your
answers because interviews are all about.
152
:Evidence of what you've done in
the past because it's then a good
153
:indicator of future performance.
154
:Being able to tell 'em about
how you have added value to the
155
:business will help them see that
you are a really credible candidate.
156
:You've got the job spec, you've
got the person spec in terms of
157
:what skills and experience they're
looking for, but you wanna take
158
:it to that next level in terms of.
159
:Okay, let me link that then to the
difference that I've made because that
160
:will help them to see I can make the same
difference to them in their organization.
161
:And then when we're thinking about the
interview panel, we can also be thinking
162
:about what's going to be important to the
different members of the panel, because
163
:you're gonna have different stakeholders
present who will all have their own
164
:agenda around why they're on panel.
165
:Obviously, your immediate
boss will be thinking about.
166
:How are you gonna add value?
167
:How are you gonna help me be successful?
168
:How are you gonna deliver what
I need to deliver for my team,
169
:for my department this year?
170
:So they're gonna be very interested in the
how and the results that you've generated.
171
:Often they'll be a member of hr.
172
:They're gonna be thinking broadly,
they're gonna be thinking about the people
173
:fit, the cultural fit, the team fit.
174
:Maybe you'll have a peer or a member of
a different department that you might
175
:collaborate with or support in your role.
176
:And they'll be thinking
about, how can you help me?
177
:How can you aid my team to be successful?
178
:Then you might have at the next level
interview, you might have your boss's
179
:boss who'll be interested in how
do you bring organizational value.
180
:How are you gonna help my department
or the organization be successful?
181
:You might have a trustee or a
member of the board on the panel,
182
:and you'll be wanting to think
about, okay, from their portfolio,
183
:what might they be interested in?
184
:Because that would also help you shape
your answers by thinking about, okay,
185
:what could be important for them to
know about me in order to say yes.
186
:So that's our third area.
187
:Our fourth area is.
188
:Thinking about how you communicate.
189
:So if you find it hard to
talk about yourself and your
190
:strengths and your skills, because
maybe you are quite humble.
191
:Maybe you feel you don't want to brag.
192
:Maybe you have bad experiences
before you've been told don't.
193
:And show off.
194
:And obviously we wanna work through that.
195
:So some of that is the mindset work,
but also what you can do to start
196
:helping yourself is to start talking
more about what you do on a daily basis.
197
:So it becomes more natural and it
becomes part of what you do in your
198
:communications, which will generally help
in a work context about your visibility.
199
:So thinking, okay, what have
I done today that's been.
200
:Great.
201
:How can I link it to my
skills, to my leadership style?
202
:And if you don't feel comfortable
doing it at work, in terms of talking
203
:about what you've achieved, doing it
at home with a partner, with friend,
204
:just practicing telling them, in a very
factual evidence based way, what you did
205
:and how you did it, and the complexities
that you navigated in order to deliver
206
:something or to, make something happen,
it'll help you get more comfortable.
207
:And when you are going for a
leadership role, you've got to
208
:watch out for that tricky balance
between operational and strategy.
209
:'cause depending on what level
you are, sometimes you can
210
:get stuck in the operational.
211
:But if you're going for that next
leadership role, they want to see
212
:your strategic approach as well.
213
:So it's definitely about making sure
you are demonstrating that balance of
214
:the strategy and the how do I do it?
215
:And then our final area is to create
personal impact because we also, as
216
:well as all that factored evidence
and data, we also want to be showing
217
:who we are as a person and showing
our enthusiasm of our passion for
218
:the role of excitement for the role.
219
:'cause that's contagious and
you want to be conveying that.
220
:But sometimes if you are nervous,
what happens is you're so focused on
221
:containing your nerves that enthusiasm
and that excitement gets all squashed.
222
:So it's thinking about making
sure you are conveying that.
223
:And one way to do that is to think
about this role that I'm going for.
224
:What sparks joy for me,
personally about that role?
225
:Is it the mission?
226
:Is it the purpose?
227
:Is it the people?
228
:Is it the project?
229
:Is it the tools even that I might be
working with, but finding something
230
:that sparks joy and being able to
think about how you communicate that
231
:in the interview setting as well.
232
:Also giving yourself the
permission not to be perfect.
233
:'cause sometimes when we
go for an interview, think
234
:gotta do a perfect delivery.
235
:I can't make any mistakes.
236
:But actually it's okay to show
your human side to the panel.
237
:They're human too.
238
:And sometimes it can be enough to, show
that personality piece, if you like.
239
:I remember I went for an interview
when I was leaving my HR director
240
:role, and I was applying for a career
coaching job at Social Enterprise.
241
:I hadn't had an interview for seven
years, and I had to do a role play
242
:at the beginning of the interview as
well, so I was quite anxious about it.
243
:So when I went in and met the panel,
I said, oh, please be gentle with me.
244
:I haven't had an interview.
245
:For seven years and it just broke the ice.
246
:It lightened the atmosphere a bit.
247
:It gave me permission to not
be, a hundred percent perfect.
248
:Lucky I did get the job, so it worked.
249
:But just thinking about what would make
you feel able to relax a little bit,
250
:using your body language, smiling is
all great ways to show your personality
251
:and to break the ice a little bit.
252
:You can be, and you should be
proactive in the interview.
253
:So creating the right
environment for yourself.
254
:If you're someone who naturally
is quite engaging and you would
255
:normally want to lighten that depth,
so then do that in the interview.
256
:It doesn't have to all be
the responsibility of the
257
:panel to make you feel good.
258
:You can think about how can I show
my personality and enable me to
259
:feel more, a bit more relaxed at
the beginning of the interview.
260
:And then the final thing is to be
intentional about the impression and the
261
:impact you want to have in the interview.
262
:So thinking about how
you want to come across.
263
:In that interview setting,
bearing in mind what the job is.
264
:Do you want to be seen
as a safe pair of hands?
265
:Do you want to be seen as a go-getter?
266
:Do you want to be seen as a people person?
267
:And being intentional going into
that interview , intentional
268
:about the impression and the
impact that you want to create.
269
:Is also part of that, being
proactive in the interview process.
270
:I know that's a lot to think about.
271
:I'll just recap for you.
272
:We've got reframing selling into
providing data and information
273
:for them to make a decision about.
274
:What you've done what your successes
are, what you're bringing managing your
275
:inner critic to create a positive mindset
around the whole interview experience.
276
:Getting clear about what the interview
panel need to know about you in terms
277
:of your unique selling points and the
impact you've had on the business.
278
:Understanding the different perspectives
on the interview panel and what
279
:different people might be looking for.
280
:Starting to practice talking about
yourself, that's something you
281
:find very tricky, and creating
personal impact, letting your joy,
282
:enthusiasm, excitement, or personality
come through in the interview.
283
:I hope that's given you
some food for thought.
284
:I hope it's given you some ideas
about where you might need to
285
:tweak your interview performance.
286
:And like I always say, if it's
something that you feel you need
287
:support with, then please do message me.
288
:Get in touch.
289
:I love, love, love interview coaching
because it can make a real difference to.
290
:How you perform on your day and making
sure you are getting the job offer.
291
:You're not the runner up, you're
actually getting the job offer.
292
:Thank you so much for listening
to this episode of the Unstuck
293
:and Unstoppable podcast.
294
:I have lots of free resources you
can access on my website, ww.career
295
:tree coaching.co
296
:uk, and I'll also put
links in the show notes.
297
:If you found this episode
helpful, then please subscribe
298
:so you don't miss the next one.
299
:And please do share it with a
friend and leave me a review
300
:and I will personally thank you.
301
:Remember, you're capable of more
than you know, shine brightly.
302
:Lead boldly and unlock the
extraordinary potential within you.
303
:Be unstoppable.